Horse racing’s annual “we swear we’re fixing things” convention rolled on in Tucson this week, and NYRA president David O’Rourke got on stage to announce the latest shiny object meant to convince horseplayers the game is finally leveling the playing field.
Starting next month, NYRA is going to throttle computer-assisted wagering down to the same six-bets-per-second speed limit that retail bettors face once the clock hits one minute to post.
Cute idea. Adorable, even.
But here’s the problem: CAWs are light-years past a tweak like this.
While the traditional horse racing guard is figuring out 2010 things, CAWs are plugged into the Matrix, downloading and digesting data even NYRA doesn’t know exists.
A lot more needs to be done to stop the bleeding if horse racing wants to level CAWs-influence, which is now estimated to be over 30-percent of wagering pools (at least).
“Six Bets Per Second” Sounds Big… Until You Remember CAWs Don’t Play Like Humans
O’Rourke framed this as a guardrail to reduce the late odds free-fall that has every horseplayer in America throwing their remote when their 5-1 becomes 9-5 after the race starts.
But anyone who understands how CAWs operate heard this and laughed.
You cap them at six bets per second? Fine.
They’ll just make six gigantic bets per second.
Or they’ll split volume across teams.
Or they’ll fire in different pools simultaneously.
Or they’ll restructure the batching behavior so the limit barely matters.
The idea that this solves late odds drops is… optimistic. Very.
Everyone On the Panel Knows This Isn’t Stopping CAWs — It’s Just Slowing Them Down 2%
Even Scott Daruty of Elite Turf Club basically said the quiet part out loud:
“CAW will still be able to place large wagers under the six-bets-per-second restriction.”
Translation: This changes absolutely nothing for us.
Meanwhile economist Marshall Gramm has already shown that tracks with earlier CAW cutoffs reduce volatility mostly in the win pool only. Every other pool? Still wild west.
And when Pat Cummings asked the obvious question — basically, “How do you stop CAWs from just hammering exactas at full blast inside that one-minute window?” — the answer was:
“We’re going to… get cycle times up… and make a new metric.”
A metric.
Great.
The bettors getting cooked by late CAW dumps will be thrilled to know there’s now a metric measuring exactly how cooked they are.
Raw Data Feeds Going Public? Cool. CAWs Already Have Ten Years Of Super Data And Models You’ll Never Catch
NYRA also says they might make raw data feeds public next month.
Nice move. Transparency matters.
But let’s not pretend releasing a bag of breadcrumbs is going to stop the guys who have been eating steak dinners for a decade.
The CAWs operate with:
- servers colocated with tote hubs
- predictive models built on billions of rows of historic data
- real-time pricing engines
- volatility detection
- synchronization across tracks
- sophisticated pooling logic
Retail bettors getting a CSV file of pool totals isn’t closing the gap. It’s adding a flashlight to a gunfight.
This Move Is Mostly PR — Because Racing Desperately Needs PR
Cummings even said it on the panel:
“You all could use some really good PR to explain a lot of things.”
This is exactly that…PR.
A gesture.
A headline.
Something tracks can point at when horseplayers complain about the 11-1 dropping to 4-1 at the half-mile pole.
NYRA wants to show they’re “doing something.”
Fair enough. Doing nothing is how racing got into this mess.
But let’s be real: CAWs are not sweating this. They will adapt instantly.
This new rule might trim some volatility, mostly in the simplest pools. But the idea that it reins in CAWs in any meaningful, competitive way?
i was born at night, but not last night.
Bottom Line: We’ll….take it?
It’s a start. But CAWs will maneuver around this before the panelists even flew home from Tucson.
If the industry wants real change, it needs more than throttles and soundbites.
It needs a full rebuild of how the money flows, who gets access to what, and when.
Until then?
Retail bettors are counting down the days until they can’t stomach getting their ass handed to them everyday.
Leave a Reply